• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pelham Pizza: Savor Authentic Italian Flavors with a Seafood Twist

Pelham Pizza, located in Pelham, NY, is a beloved spot known for its top-quality pizza and inviting atmosphere. With a variety of pizza options, including specialty choices like the flavorful Chicken Cutlet Pizza and the fresh Salad Pizza, there is something for everyone to enjoy. Customers rave about the delectable crust and generous toppings, emphasizing the attentive service and welcoming environment. Pelham Pizza's longstanding reputation for excellence and personalized customer service make it a standout choice for a satisfying dining experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Pelham Pizza is a must-visit for delicious, high-quality Italian cuisine.

Pelham Pizza at a glance

  • Address 113 Fifth Ave Pelham, NY 10803
  • Phone (914) 738-3554
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Pelham Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

David Hale Smith
5

The owners of Wise Hardware recommended this spot while we were getting supplies in their store. What a killer spot! The guys making the pizzas were very helpful to a couple of strangers while serving up dozens of happy regulars. Incredible flavor perfect crust undercarriage on these traditional pies. And absolutely the best grandma slice I’ve ever had in my life! Hot honey and Gorgonzola finale! Oh my. Reasonable prices. Cold beer, too. Highly recommend!

The Sophisticated Shopper LLC
5

I first came to Pelham Pizzaria as a teenager in 1978, and this July 2025, I returned with my wife and daughter—what a full-circle moment. Now run by the original owner’s son, Pino, the pizza is exactly as I remembered: hot, delicious, and full of flavor. One bite and I felt 17 again. Thank you, Pino, and the whole team, for making me, Sandy, and our daughter Victoria feel like we have two homes—Pelham and Chicago. The food, the service, the memories—it’s all five stars. We’ll be back. —Robert Zaffino

Giselle Roberts
5

So I was hormonal and had a craving- a "need for cheese" if you will. I ordered an extra cheese pizza with my toppings via GrubHub and put in the order details that I needed them to be generous with the cheese. They understood. They took care of me. They always do. Love these guys.

S.C. Tomlinson
5

One word, DELICIOUS!!! This place is a gem! The environment is friendly and family orientated. At first walking in, I thought it was just all pizzas. Don't get me wrong, the variety of pizzas offered is great but when I looked to the left and saw wine, fried calamari, soups being served at the table, I quickly realized that this isn't just some regular pizza spot. Stop in, have a sit, and grab something good from the menu. Great for family night out where parents can have a grown up meal and the kids can enjoy a slice!

Jessica Rivera
5

Intown for work, didn’t really think I would get this pizza, but I was getting some for my friend. A bit on the cost of your side since it was eight dollars for two plain sizes that I used to pay a dollar for down in the city, but we’re not in the cities so I’ll be fair. It was quick service. It seems like the shop had its regulars and I got out within five minutes and it was a safe meal so a win.

Phil Geoffrey
5

Ordered the eggplant parmigiana hero. Perfect. Just the right amount of cheese, bread and eggplant. You will have to drive pretty far to beat this place. Prices are very reasonable. Will definitely come back.

Eddie Cheaz
5

Am amazing local pizzeria and restaurant that's family oriented and a great low-key place to hang out with friends and family. Pizza is amazing, their food is 5 star with nonna sized portions, and carry excellent Italian beer from Biella, Italy!! My only wish is that they carried Italian desserts like home-made cannoli, even if on a small scale, first come, first serve basis.

Mike
5

Classic old-school pizza joint - as good as it gets. Best sausage slice I have ever had. Best lasagna slice I have ever had. The crust is always crispy and they are substantial slices.

Location

  • Pelham Pizza
    Pelham Pizza
    113 Fifth Ave Pelham, NY 10803 Hotline: (914) 738-3554

Pelham Pizza is a delightful Italian and seafood pizza joint located in Pelham, NY. This restaurant offers a plethora of options for pizza enthusiasts, from classic cheese pizza to specialty choices like Chicken Cutlet Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Pizza. With a variety of toppings and a selection of pizza by the slice, Pelham Pizza caters to all taste preferences.

One of the standout features of Pelham Pizza is its welcoming ambiance, described by customers as warm and inviting. The staff are known to provide excellent service, making diners feel right at home. Whether you're dining in or ordering takeout, Pelham Pizza ensures a pleasant experience for all.

The quality of the food at Pelham Pizza is consistently praised by patrons. The crust is said to be delectable, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. Customers rave about dishes like the Spinach Pizza, Salad Pizza, and the Combination Pizza with six toppings. It's clear that Pelham Pizza takes pride in their culinary creations, resulting in top-notch dishes that keep customers coming back for more.

Overall, Pelham Pizza is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious and satisfying pizza in a friendly atmosphere. The combination of excellent food, attentive service, and a welcoming environment makes this restaurant a standout choice for pizza lovers. Give Pelham Pizza a try and experience the flavors that keep locals coming back for more.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments